An open walk in wardrobe is one of the few built-in items a buyer can judge from a drawing, because there are no doors to hide behind. What you specify — carcass material, bay widths, hanging heights, drawer layout, edge treatment — is exactly what the client sees on site. That visibility is also why the specification gets challenged: designer, builder and procurement manager will each propose a different alternative, and the one that survives is usually the one backed by drawings, samples and an itemised price rather than preference.
This guide sets out how to compare those alternatives on the same basis, using the walk-in wardrobe families SANTERSON manufactures as worked examples. Each item below is made-to-measure, so the comparison turns on configuration and documentation, not on swapping catalogue SKUs.
First: fix what the alternative is actually replacing
Half of all wardrobe value engineering goes wrong at this step. "Change the open walk-in to something cheaper" can mean three different things, and each has a different cost consequence further down the job:
- A change of enclosure only — the same layout, but hung with doors instead of left open. This is the cheapest change on paper and often the most expensive on site, because door runs need track tolerances, opening clearances and a level finished floor that an open run does not.
- A change of format — walk-in replaced by wardrobes in the bedroom. This frees floor area but moves storage into a room that may not have the wall length for it.
- A change of construction — factory-made cabinetry replaced with site-built joinery, or the reverse. This shifts cost from the product to labour and programme.
Decide which of the three you are considering before requesting a comparison price. Otherwise suppliers quote against their own assumption, and the numbers do not line up.
Compare five walk-in formats on the same floor plan
SANTERSON's Walk-in Wardrobes collection covers the main layout responses to a spare room or corridor alcove. Draw each one over the same measured plan and count three things: linear metres of hanging, floor area left to walk on, and how many runs are visible from the bedroom doorway.
- Open Walk in Wardrobes — runs without doors. Lowest hardware content, no track or hinge schedule to coordinate, and the fastest install of the group. The trade is dust and the requirement that everything hanging stays presentable, which matters most in hotel suites and display villas.
- L Shaped Walk in Wardrobes — two runs meeting at a corner. The corner is the decision point: an open corner keeps both runs readable, while a returned run loses usable depth to the return itself.
- U Shaped Walk in Wardrobes — three runs and the highest storage density of the group, but it narrows the walking aisle. Check the clear aisle before approving; this is the format most often over-specified in narrow rooms.
- Island Walk in Wardrobes — a low central unit with drawer and top storage. It adds worktop height for folding, and it needs more floor area than any other option here, so it belongs only where the room can absorb it.
- Glass Walk in Wardrobes — glazed fronts on the same carcass logic. This is the usual alternative when a client wants the open look but not the exposed finish, and it changes the specification materially: glazing type, frame profile and interior lighting all move onto the schedule.
Where the room will not take a walk-in at all, the honest alternative is an open wardrobe run in the bedroom rather than a compressed walk-in. Freestanding open wardrobes and wall-mounted open wardrobes use the same made-to-measure carcass and finish options, sit shallower than a walk-in room, and keep the hanging visible without requiring a dedicated room. Metal frame open wardrobes are the third variant worth pricing when a lighter visual profile or a slim upright structure is wanted against a tiled or finished wall.
The specification points that decide the price
Once the format is chosen, an alternative is only comparable if these are identical. Ask each supplier to state them explicitly:
- Carcass substrate and thickness. Same board type and same panel thickness, or the comparison is meaningless. Also confirm what the visible face of a carcass end is — an open wardrobe exposes end panels that doors would have covered.
- Finish system. Veneer, lacquer, acrylic, melamine and wood-grain board all take the same layout but behave differently at edges and in reflected light. Request physical samples of the exact finish, not a colour name.
- Hanging configuration. Single or double hang per bay, plus how many adjustable shelves and where. This is where most "value engineered" savings hide, because reducing one shelf per bay looks trivial on a drawing and is obvious in use.
- Drawer and accessory content. Drawer counts, runners, pull-out trays, valet rods, lighting. Price these as line items so they can be reduced deliberately instead of disappearing from the quote.
- Edge and junction detail. How carcasses meet plasterboard, how a run returns at a corner, how skirting is dealt with. Open formats show every junction.
- Tolerance and setting-out responsibility. Who sets out on site, who confirms the final dimensions, and what happens if the finished floor level moves. This belongs in the order confirmation for any made-to-measure joinery.
Where an open walk-in is the right answer, and where it is not
Open walk-in runs suit rooms used by one household or one guest at a time, joinery of a finish quality good enough to be looked at, and clients who accept that hanging stays visible. They fit less well in high-turnover accommodation, in rooms opening onto a dusty external area, or where housekeeping needs something to close away.
When the objection is dust or presentation rather than layout, glazing the same carcass is usually a smaller change than re-planning the room. When the objection is floor area, move the storage out of the walk-in altogether and price an open wardrobe run in the bedroom. Either response keeps the carcass specification stable, which protects finish consistency across the rest of the joinery package.
A short checklist before you approve the alternative
- Measured drawing with finished floor and finished ceiling levels marked, not structural ones
- Aisle clearance dimension stated for walk-in layouts
- Carcass substrate, panel thickness and edge banding written on the schedule
- Physical finish sample approved and signed off by reference code
- Hanging heights, shelf counts and drawer counts listed per bay
- Lighting shown on the drawing with its wiring route identified
- Final dimensions confirmed after wet trades are complete
- Delivery, packaging and installation sequence agreed with the site programme
SANTERSON manufactures walk-in wardrobes, open wardrobes and the surrounding built-in joinery as made-to-measure work, with material and finish options specified per project. As a furniture and building materials supplier, we also produce the cabinetry, wall panelling, doors and lighting that sit alongside a wardrobe package, so an alternative can be assessed across the whole joinery scope instead of one room in isolation — useful when changing the wardrobe specification would otherwise break finish consistency elsewhere. Send the measured plan and your current wardrobe schedule and we will price the open walk-in against each alternative on the same basis, with every line item shown separately.