Two suppliers can quote what looks like the same oak wardrobe and still produce very different furniture. One sends a flat-pack carcass with a veneered door; the other delivers a made-to-measure unit with solid timber framing, matched drawer banks and ironmongery you can actually open every day. The quotation numbers alone will not tell you which is which.
If you are buying wardrobes for a villa renovation, an apartment development or a hotel room floor, the sample and the written proposal are where the decision gets made. Below is the checklist we use to compare them line by line, using our own Oak Solid Wood Wardrobes as the reference point so you can see what a complete submission should contain.
Start With What the Sample Actually Proves
A sample is only useful if it answers questions your finished wardrobes will be judged on. A single door panel tells you about colour and edge treatment. It tells you nothing about carcass construction, hinge loading or how the unit behaves against an uneven floor. Ask each supplier for a small assembled section instead: one bay of carcass with two doors, one drawer and a shelf.
- Timber and grain. Look at the edge banding and the rail-and-stile junction. Where solid timber is used, the grain should run continuously across the joint with no print-through or filler line.
- Finish build. Run your hand along the panel field and then across the frame. A good spray finish feels continuous; a thin finish shows a ridge where the sealer stops.
- Hardware in action. Open and close the doors and drawers repeatedly, with the unit loaded. Soft-close behaviour, drawer side travel and door reveal consistency are visible on a sample and invisible on a spec sheet.
- Interior fit and finish. Check that shelf pin holes are drilled cleanly, that the back panel is captured in a groove rather than nailed to the face, and that the interior surfaces are as finished as the exterior.
Keep the physical samples from every bidder, labelled with the quotation number. When a question arises during production, you will be comparing against an agreed reference rather than a photograph in an email thread.
Read the Proposal for What Is Missing
Most wardrobe proposals that cause trouble are not wrong, they are incomplete. Compare each quotation against the same list of items, and treat any blank cell as a cost or a variation waiting to happen.
| Line item | What a complete proposal states |
|---|---|
| Scope and dimensions | Room-by-room schedule, overall heights and depths, floor-to-ceiling treatment, skirting and architrave deductions |
| Construction method | Carcass material and thickness, door construction, back-panel fixing method, load-bearing shelf spans |
| Finish specification | Species, cut, grain pattern, stain or lacquer system, sheen level, number of coats, touch-up policy |
| Internal layout | Hanging zones, drawer banks, shelf counts, trouser and shoe provisions, lighting provision |
| Hardware schedule | Hinge and slide make and model, load rating, soft-close items, handle or push-to-open choice |
| Interface conditions | Who prepares walls, floors and ceilings; scribe and filler details; tolerance allowance for out-of-plumb surfaces |
| Commercial terms | Packaging method, freight mode and incoterms, delivery address, installation responsibility, snag and replacement process |
Two quotations at the same price diverge most often in the last three rows. A low figure that excludes site preparation, on-site fixing and touch-up work is not a lower-cost wardrobe; it is a wardrobe with a separate invoice later.
Score Construction Quality, Not Appearance
Once the samples are in hand, score them against the same criteria. Appearance is subjective and easy to argue about; construction detail is not. We build our Oak Solid Wood Wardrobes as part of the Solid Wood Wardrobes collection for residential projects, and each unit is specified to the space rather than taken from a fixed size grid: made-to-measure sizing, material and finish options, and a layout tailored to the project. That means the proposal stage is where you lock in the details, because nothing arrives as a standard module you can adjust on site.
- Carcass thickness and fixing. Ask what panel thickness is used for sides, tops and bottoms, and how units are joined to each other and restrained to the wall.
- Door stability. Solid timber doors in wide sizes need construction that accommodates seasonal movement. Ask how the supplier handles wide panels and what finish system is applied to both faces.
- Drawer boxes. Compare dovetail or routed joint construction, slide rating and the depth actually available once the runner is fitted.
- Shelf spans. A shelf that sags under hung garments is a specification error. Ask for maximum unsupported span for the board you are being quoted.
Check How Customisation Is Priced
Bespoke joinery is where suppliers separate themselves, and it is also where hidden cost lives. Ask each bidder to price the same three changes (one extra drawer bank, one different door style, one finish change) so you can see how variation is handled before you need it.
Our Custom Furniture Manufacturer service covers design and prototyping, bespoke material finishes and textures, OEM production and flexible order quantities. A useful question to put to any supplier: at what point does a change stop being free and start being a charge, and who signs off the revised drawing before it reaches the workshop? The answer tells you how the factory handles revisions in practice.
Drawings matter more than renders. A perspective image can hide a shallow drawer or an awkward door swing. Insist on dimensioned elevations for every unit, with door and drawer openings shown against the fixed elements in the room: lights, switches, skirting and curtains.
Compare Delivery, Installation and Snag Terms
Wardrobes are usually installed after flooring and decoration, which puts them at the end of the programme and makes them the first item to absorb somebody else's delay. Compare how each supplier proposes to handle that risk.
- Packaging. Ask whether units ship flat-packed, pre-assembled or as carcass-and-door sets, and how door faces are protected between containers and site.
- Freight and documentation. Confirm the mode of transport, the paperwork supplied with the shipment and who handles customs clearance at destination. Our Furniture Logistics and Door-to-door Delivery service covers freight forwarding by sea, air and rail together with the shipping documents and container loading plan.
- Site readiness. Agree in writing which trades prepare the openings, and what tolerance range the joinery is built to accept.
- Installation and handover. Clarify who fixes, aligns and touches up on site, and how snags are recorded and closed out. Our Furniture Installation and After-sales Support service includes installation, inspection with the client, warranty coverage, spare parts and replacement where needed.
A Shortlist of Questions to Send Back to Bidders
Send the same short table to every supplier and ask them to complete it. The replies will re-rank your options faster than any brochure.
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Can you supply an assembled sample bay with doors and drawers? | Reveals carcass and hardware quality that a door sample hides |
| What is the maximum unsupported shelf span for the quoted board? | Prevents sagging in hanging zones |
| Which hinge and slide models are included, and at what load rating? | Hardware drives service life more than finish does |
| What is charged for a drawer addition or finish change after drawing approval? | Exposes variation pricing before it becomes a claim |
| Who prepares walls and floors, and what tolerance is allowed? | Avoids site-fit disputes on out-of-plumb surfaces |
| What is the snag and replacement process after handover? | Determines how defects are actually closed |
Where Our Own Submissions Stand
For wardrobe packages we handle the whole chain in one place: space planning and drawings, manufacturing and quality control, packaging and freight, then installation and after-sales support. If your project also needs cabinetry, doors, wall panelling, flooring or lighting from the same coordination point, our Turnkey Interior Project Solutions scope covers villa, hospitality and office work under one programme.
Send us your room dimensions, the finish direction you are working to, and the target handover date. We will return dimensioned drawings, a construction specification and an itemised quotation in the same format as this checklist, so you can place it beside your other bids without translating between them.
Talk to us about oak solid wood wardrobes for your project. Request physical samples, dimensioned drawings and an itemised quotation you can place beside your other bids.