Three quotations for the same villa or hotel fit-out can differ by a wide margin, and the lowest figure is rarely the cheapest outcome once variations, replacement orders and rework are counted. The problem is almost never pricing alone: proposals arrive with different scopes, different levels of detail and different assumptions about who handles what between the factory floor and the finished room. Comparing them properly means normalising the scope first, then reading each line item for what it leaves out.
Start from one scope document, not three interpretations
Send every supplier the same package: drawings or marked-up plans, room-by-room schedules, finish selections and a written statement of what is inside and outside the boundary. Ask each supplier to return a bill of quantities in your format rather than their own catalogue layout. When proposals come back structured the same way, differences become visible instead of buried.
A single scope document also exposes gaps quickly. If one turnkey furniture and building materials supplier prices the joinery but not the architraves, while another prices both, you are not comparing two prices — you are comparing two buildings. Write the exclusions section into the request for quotation, so silence on a trade is treated as exclusion, not assumption.
Check what each line item actually contains
Custom work hides cost in specification depth. For built-in items such as custom built-in kitchen cabinets, a quotation should state panel substrate, surface finish, door profile, dimensions for each run, hardware make and model, and whether installation is included. A line reading "kitchen cabinetry, as per drawing" invites variation orders later.
Apply the same test across categories: flooring to state board thickness and wear layer; lighting to state lamp type, driver and mounting detail; sanitary ware to state trap orientation and cistern type. Where a supplier lists finishes generically — "matte lacquer", "high gloss", "wood veneer" — ask which substrate sits underneath and how the edges are handled. Edge treatment and hardware grade are where two visually identical proposals separate in price and in performance.
Compare service scope, not just product scope
| Line to compare | Ask each supplier |
|---|---|
| Design and detailing | Are shop drawings, 3D renderings and material schedules included, and who signs off on them before production starts? |
| Custom and OEM work | Can sizes, finishes and hardware be changed without repricing the whole lot? What prototyping step is offered before bulk production? |
| Packaging and freight | Which Incoterms apply? Is container loading planned by the supplier, and who prepares customs paperwork? |
| Delivery and handover | Is delivery to site or to port? Is on-site installation, inspection and snagging included? |
| After sales | What is covered, for how long, and how are replacement parts shipped and fitted? |
A supplier offering only manufacturing is quoting a different job from one covering project services from design coordination through production, logistics and installation. Put both in the same column and add the cost of the local trades you would need to hire to close the gap: freight forwarding, customs clearance, storage, install labour, and a contingency for damaged or missing items.
Read the assumptions behind the price
Ask each supplier to state, in writing, what their number assumes about quantities, site access, moisture and substrate conditions, and responsibility for measurement. Overseas manufacturing for Australian projects raises one more question: who verifies that dimensions were taken from the finished floor levels and wall setouts on site, rather than from drawing dimensions alone. Custom joinery ordered off unverified drawings is the most common cause of a second production run.
Watch for prices quoted against a currency and rate you cannot lock in, and for validity periods shorter than your decision timeline. Ask what triggers a repricing event: timber and hardware costs, freight rates, or a change in finish selection.
Score the proposals, then verify before signing
A simple scoring sheet keeps the comparison honest. Rate each proposal on scope completeness, specification detail, communication quality during the tender, and evidence of comparable work — completed project references in a similar building type matter more than a showroom catalogue. A supplier who answers technical questions with drawings and material samples is showing you how the project will run; one who answers only with a discount is not.
- Request physical samples of every specified finish, and check them against the sample board number recorded in the contract.
- Ask for a production schedule by trade and a named contact who coordinates it, rather than a general email address.
- Confirm what documentation arrives with the shipment: packing list by crate, assembly drawings, hardware schedule, care instructions.
- Check that after-sales commitments name parts availability and who performs replacement work on site.
The cheapest proposal wins only when its scope matches your document line for line. Where it does not, the difference is usually a variation order waiting to be issued — and those arrive at the supplier's price, on the project's clock.
For projects requiring matched furniture, built-in joinery, wall and ceiling finishes, lighting and sanitary ware from one production source, contact SANTERSON to receive a line-by-line quotation against your own scope document.